Black Preaching Network

Salvation is it eternal regardless of the circumstances or not come on lets get everyone’s opinion

But what is your take on what would have happened if the prodigal son or anyone who had received salvation backslides by rejecting the Father, His Son, the Holy Ghost and totally turned away from the faith and DIED without having repented or had the opportunity to return to the fold. Would that person be heading for hell or heaven? This is a conversation that came up with a couple of my work colleague when we were in an after discussion on Luke 15:11-32 so I would be interested in having a discussion and receiving everyone's point of view.

Views: 3670

Replies are closed for this discussion.

Replies to This Discussion

You still don't get it. I read them. So what? Your position is simply "once saved always saved," based on the belief that all it takes is to believe and I said "Satan is the biggest believer and he is not making it."


What your not seeing and it is really because your not trying to see it but because your a stinking Reverend it puts you over people. Talk about stinking thinking! It is the same belief system you have that allows you to call yourself a Reverend and I even demonstrated where that belief came from and it is right out of history.


Your saying my thinking is flawed, but you never really come back with an explanation of where the flaw is. I mean stop looking at life through your eyes. Maybe look at what your saying starting with calling yourself a Reverend to be very flawed thinking. It is a label that keeps you from seeing anything else.


It is the gerundive of the verb revereri (to respect) which may be taken as a gerundive or a passive periphrastic, therefore meaning [one who is] to be respected/must be respected. The Reverend is therefore equivalent to The Hono(u)rable or The Venerable.


Honestly, although you would think of yourself as being honest and open, your not. I have given you some pretty good reasoning behind my statements and while you think I should read what you write and I have, you really don't believe I have a right to state another and different point of view and when I do, you just toss it aside, which is a certain sign of

arrogance - overbearing pride evidenced by a superior manner toward inferiors


"In the meantime, my time posting to you has come to an end. I'm weary of wasting my time with you. You have been dismissed." REV if that is not arrogance, I will repent. You even calling yourself a REVEREND is a prime example of that arrogance.


What are you going to do if Jesus decides that He will toss you aside as you have tossed me aside? With all of your biblical knowledge, how is it that you cannot understand that what you do to me, you do to God Himself? I know, I know, you can do what you want and still be Reverend Christian that is once saved always saved no matter what you do. That really is sad.

It is quite an unfurtunate thing a believer backsliding and to die thereof.The difference between Peter and Judas is the ability to accept the grace as time permitted. Judas allowed the grace to expire.His office another took. Expired grace would mean digrace. The perfect office ot the evetually is heven. Office taken means hell.All the same

Dear    Rev. Anthony R. Watson, AMECHI GODSON, Dr Sarah Carrol, I believe the greatest lesson Jesus came to teach us was love and compassion one for one another.  And through love we as children of God ought to gather souls into the kingdom.  However, after seeing the way you guys relate to each other if I was a sinner I might think twice.  Guys we who are called by God and set apart ought to be able to have a civilised discussion without mud slinging, if any of you truly believe in the name that is above all name then I suggest you consider what has come out of your mouth, pen because what has come out in thoughts and deeds comes from the heart and it is therefore the thing that will truly defile you not the thing that has gone in but what comes out.  Therefore I suggest unless you consider yourselves to be as the pharsees and saducees thinking you are more important and better than anyone else that you reread what you have all written in regards to the name calling ,putting down and derogative treatment of each and duly ask for forgiveness.  The most important thing that each of you are to know is God created us in His own image and in His sight all are precious therefore calling one of God's creation stinking because you disagree is really not acceptable for someone who possesses the light, undermining another by making them feel inferior is unacceptable because man was created in the likeness of God and in His sight we are precious.

You know I am assuming that we are all adult here and the fact that there are titles in front of your names this should mean that you are no longer babes desiring milk but have become fully pledge mature students place in a position of authority responsible for the shepharding of Gods people therefore needing more than all to set an example.

Now this discussion as with any that I set is done in order to help each one of us grow in our walk with Christ because it ought to make us look and consider the way in which we who pertain to be the beacon conduct ourselves in our walk in order to draw others to Christ.


Until the return of Christ none of us is perfect and will not be perfected without Him but that does not mean we cannot strive for perfection which is best done by showing due regard and love one for another. 


Brothers and Sisters you do not have to  insult each other to get your point across only satan need to do that , children of /God only need to show there light. 


Stay bless and please if you intent to continue with this discussion pray first before you make your responses. 


Thank you




Hello dear Angela,

I thank you for the points you raised in your post. It is absolutely true that we need to show love and compassion, especially when others disagree with our spiritual view point. However, this does not negate the fact that the scripture warns us against heresies, or false doctrines. And as a minister of the gospel, God would hold us responsible if we compromise on the truth in any given environment. Nevertheless, this we must do in a polite and respectful manner. In view of the fact that our doctrinal opponent could become our proponent later on.

Besides, that one called another names may not be motivated by hatred. In some situations the Word of God can rebuke harshly. Don't forget that Christ called the Pharisees names like, fox, white sepulcher, or even devil. Does it imply that he hates them? Absolutely not. He loves them and wants them to turn a new live.

A pastor or Bible communicator may be harsh on his audience, yet he loves and is compassionate towards them. Nonetheless, on the part of the audience it takes the virtue of humility to listen than to oppose the communicator. And also we should not forget that in God's economic, he has graciously blessed his imperfect family with different spiritual gifts. All are not called to the communication gift. Are they? Not at all.

Furthermore, we often emphasizes on love, which is the right thing, most of us a have negligible, low degree of this spiritual virtue. And We sincerely substitute or confuse  this virtue with common or establishment love. The type of love both unbelievers as well as believers could practice.

Finally, over the years in life, I have learn this powerful spiritual principle, that it is not the man, but his message that counts. For we all have foot of clay. May the good Lord show us understanding be gracious to us all, amen.

I would think the definition of heresy is to preach other than what is there. I am not sure of the Spiritual gift of communication? The other thing in grievous error is that I do not belong to your church. You are not my teacher. Having said that then you do not have a right to talk harshly to me. You may talk to your congregation that way, granted, but not here and not with me you won't. One reason is, the only way one can know if they belong to Jesus is by our love one for the other.


Having said that, you have failed to show in scripture where it says specifically, "once saved always saved regardless of what one does or does not do." If you are preaching that, then you are in error again, because it does not say that in scripture. That is like saying that Jim Jones was saved after passing out the cool aide. There are numerous other examples where, "once saved always saved regardless of what one does or does not do." 


What scripture does say is that, "those led by the Spirit of God are the sons of God." It also says very clearly, "blessed are the peacemakers for they are the children of God." I also says that if we do not keep the commandments we do not love God and one of those commandments is keeping the Sabbath. When we decide that we do not keep the Sabbath or the commandments, we place ourselves above God and make a new set of rules to go by.


But the saddest thing in all of this, with all the ministers around and with all of the congregations affected, we could be working in love and unity to turn things around, because by faith we can do all things through Christ. I think it would be heresy to teach otherwise, but why we are not doing all things through Christ to end starvation and other problems is because we simply do not believe we can. That is not keeping the faith.


What is important are two things. One having a heart for God and secondly, having God's heart and if those to things are in line in a persons life they will be motivated by His heart to represent God's love and will to all people on earth. Nothing short of that will work. If we have God's heart we will be working to end starvation and deal with homelessness, sickness, disease and care for those in prison. Starvation, homelessness, sickness, disease and prisons are a representation of the work of the devil and the workers of iniquity. One is on one side of the fence or the other.


My heart is heavy though, because there should be enough people that have a heart for God to stand together against the work of the devil because Satan is but an angel and all power was taken away from Satan on the cross, that is unless we with our confession give it back to Satan. If we are in the body of Christ then we also have the ability like Jesus to stop the enemy. That is the faith. To work to do less is not having faith.


"Finally, over the years in life, I have learn this powerful spiritual principle, that it is not the man, but his message that counts."  What matters is what one does in life. Anyone can talk a good game. WE do not have all foot of clay. It does not say that in scripture anywhere. I personally stand on the rock which is Jesus. There is no clay in any of that. It is a solid and stead fast footing. For I know in whom I have believed and that He is able to keep that which I have committed to Him against that day.


hen we have fellowship together, we are given the gifts of Eye and Ear. We see that most hearts are white and black, before they listen to the Word of God. After that we see again, and see that the black become white, by the grace of God. We have been taught by GOD that "Salvation is to be approved by God, salvation should not be approved by man". Salvation is a precious gift from God for His elect. Not all followers have FAITH, faith is given by God to His chosen people. "The plants that are not planted by God will be rooted up". David said:"Make me understand  LORD that I may live." It is true that only GOD gives us CORRECT understanding and that we may live. Jesus said;"You should be PERFECT, as your Father is PERFECT". We praise God for giving us a PERFECT EXAMPLE to follow. The Way of Life in Jesus is our TOTAL example to follow. We have lived in the HOLY WAY OF CHRIST for many years. We understand now Lord Jesus' Way of Life is to be our Way of Life to approach to our Holy Living FATHER in heaven, from Whom we have obtained LOTS of  Mysteries of GOD. The unfaithful servants of GOD will NEVER be given anything from GOD. A man lives not from bread alone, but from the WORD coming out from  the Mouth of GOD. Jesus said that the world will not see ME again, but you will see ME. It is true that whoever has been trained, taught and guided by the Spirit of Christ, they all belong to Christ. And all followers of Christ ARE ABLE TO SEE CHRIST in this life time.(JOHN 14:21/23) Jesus reveals to the faithful followers only who have been approved by GOD. A servant is to be faithful to his Master ONLY, a servant should never does anything that is not told by his Master. A servant who is always doing his own thing that is different from his Master, it is because he has other masters/gods that lead him; therefore all his followers will only follow him, they are no more in the group where Christ is. "My sheep hear My VOICE and they follow ME". The Dove, the Holy Spirit of GOD will enjoy where Christ is. The Dove will fly away where other VOICE that is different with Christ. Dear brothers and sisters in the LORD, How can they preach if they are not sent by GOD??? They will preach their own opinions and ideas, Christ said;"Whatever is out of a man is out of his heart, and it may defile people". Only the Holy Spirit of God can save a person's soul, all other spirits will only make the followers getting far and far and far away from GOD. for "your way is not MY WAY" saith The Lord of Hosts.

Salvation happens internally and is manifested externally,  We can only see the External but GOD alone  knows the hearts.  For too long we have been looking at the external and sending people to Hell or heaven.  If they came to church and cried tears  and "repented" spoke in tongues and is baptized  we pat them on the back and tell them they are saved!  If not we tell them they are not saved !  How do we know for a fact that they have made it into the fold?. This is a life long  process,  We never know!.  Our Goal as Pastors and Ministers is to reconcile the world back to God and ourselves to each other.  Salvation as far as I am concerned is Gods business and not mine.   I think instead of worrying about the salvation of others, we make our calling and election sure.  Working out our own salvation with fear and trembling before GOD. Much as i have to work on my life, I do not have time to waste trying to figure out if you are going to heaven or not.  The Answer is that GOD knows ! and we do not.. While he was there eating the Pigs foods some of the Holy Folks thought that he was doomed for sure, but the bible said that "He came to himself" and all those who thought that he should have gotten what he deserved was shocked to see he was accepted !. Stop counting people in, or counting them out for any reason.  He was saved because he came to his senses. I have seen people say the sinners prayer and not come to their senses, baptized and not come to their senses, speak in tongues and not come to their senses, and furthermore I have seen those that have come to their senses and lost it.  Even so that is still my humanistic external and limited view of that individual,  God knows all, God has all the evidence and he and he alone can be the final judge.

Actually I fully agree, who really knows the heart? We may be able to see conditions of the heart, but that is, I believe anyway that we can walk with the person and pray for them or even help them.


I had the opportunity to work at a old style rescue mission and it was rather traditional for the old pastor of the place to give an alter call every night and if the people responded they would get something to eat and a place to sleep. One could criticize the pastor, but it was the churches who funded the place that put pressure on the pastor to produce "sufficient results" to continue to fund the place. It was a bad problem and the pastor left and took over with new management and practices changed, where anyone that came to the place would get something to eat regardless. When the practices were changed peoples lives were turned around. 


At least from what I believe, it is not just about producing good fruit, but having good fruit produced in those lives they touch as well. Salvation for whatever reason was reduced to what happened on the cross with Jesus and the thief, but had the thief lived on instead of died, can one say that he really got the point or not? Granted he got the point for the moment, but what about a year or two or even longer. It is not up to the thief to get it, but up to the church to get it so the thief even has half a chance.


Too many in the church are doing things that they have not been called to do. When that happens the church instead of being built on the rock is often built on quicksand where there is little or no stability. Often times Jesus is not allowed to put the stones where they should be and too often times the stones are not taught to stay there until Jesus moves them. Seminaries do not often teach that, because if they did, there would not be the need for the seminary to start with in many cases. The five fold gift ministry was created by God so that believers would no longer be tossed to and fro by every wind of doctrine. Scripture does not say that God created seminaries where created so that believers would not longer be tossed to and fro by every wind of doctrine, but often time it is seminaries that come up with some of these doctrines that take people off track.


What is important out of any of this or all of this is that there really should be enough faith here that if we actually stood together and sought God for resolve, that we with all of this faith should be able to turn things around on earth. WE can do all things through Christ as long as our beliefs do not get in the way?

My Take was that there are many Doctrines of Salvation and I ascribe to one of them, Which is this (In Brief) 

1. We are Saved by Grace through faith

2. Without Repentace there is no remission of sins

3. Baptism - Outward Symbol of Inward Change

4. Holy Spirit - Power above our Human Abilities

5. If we confess our sins he is faithful to forgive us and cleanse us from all unrighteousness

6. For GOD So love the World that he gave his only begotten so so that whosoever believeth in him should not perish but have everlasting life. 


Now you many not agree with this but this,  and you may have a superior understanding or an inferior one as the case may be . However my point is  while we argue  Soteriology, another young man has just been shot,  another one of our sisters on the choir gets pregnant ,  Another Divorce just happened in the CHURCH. While we argue the finer points of Soteriology, Children are being abused right under our noses, Pastors are selling out the Gospel for money. When shall we learn that Jesus did not come to argue Theology.  He came so that we might have life and have it more abundantly,  My comments came from growing up in a Church where the Purpose of Church was to "Get Saved"  Nothing is wrong with that in and of itself but lets move on and use the Power of the Holy Ghost to revolutionize this world.  We cant do that Theologically.  We actually have to lay hands on the sick and they will recover.  We have to love one another.  


To your comment about my statement that does not concur with scripture, it all depends how you have interpreted my statement.  If you are thinking that I am saying that one could loose their salvation, I am not saying that.   Because the whole Idea of my statement is to say that I am not in the business of Soteriologial Assignments.  I teach my Church that each person needs to be assured within himself  that they are saved. I teach them to work out their own salvation with fear and trembling before GOD.  I teach them to die daily and maintain a prayer life without ceasing unto the Lord!  I teach them to repent of their sins, to receive the gift of the holy Ghost and to be Baptized in the precious name of Jesus.  However after I have seen them do all that I am happy but understand that I do not make the Assignments for their  name in the lambs book of Life.  I am but a man that is trying to get in myself, far be it from me to assure you that you are all set.  My Job is to make sure the people are reconciled to God so that they can hear his voice.  My Voice means very little, My opinions on Soteriology means very little... I am just a servant of the Most high GOD.  When  you realize that maybe we could get together and do some work at the homeless shelters and  run some programs for youth etc. Help the least among us

Well thank you as well, 

I did not GO to seminary however that does not make me a novice,  I can argue the finer points of Theology with the best of them and have read enough books to probably have a couple of Advanced Degrees.  (lol)  However I thank you for keeping these Ministers on their toes. What I am totally upset about is the prostitution of this Gospel for money !  It is so widespread do sickening and disgusting.  I do not know how people stoop so low !  There is more I need to learn and clarify but as God is my witness if any one of these jokers come in my church and start with that mess, i am pulling them off the pulpit immediately.  This seed sowing doctrine has reach levels of ridiculousness that its amazing that people believe them. I dont even need to read the Bible to see that its a mess ! 


Thank You 

Pastor Anderson 

I posted a discussion titled, CONTRADICTION? Expect your comment. Thanks.
Reverend, I thank you for your educative inputs. Meanwhile, I've posted a pertinent subject in christian teaching for your reaction and from others. I titled it, CONTRADICTION?


© 2014   Created by Raliegh Jones Jr..   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service